Unable to edit website records

I had a flask application running at www.mindcruzer.com, and it was working fine. A few days back I decided to turn on https (just using the default webfaction cert), but today I decided to shut it off and just run it via http. So I went into the control panel to my website record, and selected "http". I waited a while, then went to http://www.mindcruzer.com, and to my surprise, I was looking at the directory listing for ~/webapps/mindcruzer/. When I went to https://www.mindcruzer.com I was still getting the secure site. I was confused as to why this was persisting, so I decided I would delete my app and create it again, just to be sure it wasn't some strange lingering problem with the configuration. Sure enough, it's still happening (except after I created the new app I now get a 502 when trying https). Not only that, but no changes I make to any of my website records seem to have any effect.

I am running the exact same setup I had with plain http, and yet now nothing is working.